Ideas about active intentional self-caring for ourselves so we can care for others. NCERCC recently…

The NCERCC response and letter to a recent article in The Guardian newspaper
English children’s homes are in crisis. Does Denmark hold the answers? | Children | The Guardian
On the 31st October in print and 1st November 2026 The Guardian published the article above.
It required a response and NCERCC contacted the journalists involved directly. A letter was also sent. The response (along with the article) and the letter are found below.
No acknowledgement of the response has yet been received. The letter has not yet been printed.
The response is followed by the letter
NCERCC replied to journalist, social care editor and readers editor as follows raising the numerous opportunities missed to provide insight and context.
Guardian article in this font
Evidenced based NCERCC comments in bold (slightly amended as tidied up)
Begins
Danish children’s homes are often cited as the gold standard of children’s residential care globally.
There are English homes that are recognised as world class.
98-9% of homes meet standards. 70%+ Good or better according to Ofsted. As fostering declines and residential care is there in support now is the time to speak positively of the contribution.
They are now being studied by the British government
Homes here host visitors and have long term development projects internationally.
as it tries to create a roadmap out of the crisis in which its own children’s home system has become mired.
The quotes of Josh MacAllister show he has a responsibility for the current situation.
It is documented in literature reviews that since 1946 residential child care has been negatively perceived. Recent research reviews reveal how conclusions are manufactured. New English research reports positive outcomes from residential care. Josh MacAllister does not speak from evidence. Rather his comments represent an imposition of an unevidenced view.
Last year there were 669 children living in illegal, unregistered children’s homes across England, with councils paying more than £125m of taxpayers’ money to keep them there.
True. It is also true that this situation is the result of the lack of commissioning of homes that would meet needs. Local authorities are failing to commission homes – they predominantly procure from what is available, – or provide their own response.
Overall spending on children’s homes soared 96% in five years to over £3.1bn in 2023-24, while standards have dropped,
Are you sure standards have dropped? Ofsted figs report not.
private equity firms are cashing in and a growing number of children are being sent to homes hundreds of miles away.
Yes, private profit has been attracting investment. Government could have intervened (also note Wales has not ended profit tho it claims to have done so)
The situation is dire, the children’s minister, Josh MacAlister, admits. “We now have this shadow system of unregistered, illegal homes, which is certainly not providing therapeutic support and the costs are huge,” he said. “We need big changes, a major shake up, and I spend as many hours as I can a week on children’s social care reform.”
True. But unregistered are not homes. Once they were called ‘Other arrangements’. For 15 years a small group of experienced residential and children’s rights professional were trying to get government to act. We were rebuffed. So, the questions: Why this? Why now?
Earlier this week, MacAlister visited Denmark to see how its children’s homes operate and what can be exported back to England, as part of a Department for Education review into how the sector can be improved.
How many homes in England has he visited? It is a small number.
The 140-year-old Josephine Schneider’s House, which houses 12 children and young adults aged six to 23, is starkly different from many British equivalents.
England does not have homes of 12. Josh MacAllister has called large homes ‘institutional’. The age range would seen as a safeguarding concern in England
In the centre of the house is a spacious kitchen staffed by the head chef, Rasmus, who cooks the children’s meals, lunch boxes and after-school snacks – pizza rolls are a particular favourite. He works with the children himself, encouraging them to help make the food and come grocery shopping.
The rest of the staff are all degree-level professionals in social pedagogy, a discipline focusing on psychology, child development and ethics, and they strive to recreate a traditional family home by cooking, eating and socialising with the children.
We have argued for degree and professional qualifications and been denied by successive governments. We have world class learning and development that do need a spotlight. By denying professional status residential work here is low pay.
This sort of home life is what happens in England.
“We don’t have an in-house therapist but everything we do is therapeutic,” said Mads Sørensen, deputy director of the home.
One member of staff sleeps in the house at night and wakes the children up each day at 7am. “We ask them how they like to be woken up, to help them feel safe and create that predictability, make their nervous system calm a bit,” Sørensen said.
Social Pedagogy specifically denies it is ‘therapeutic’ as this is seen as treatment in Denmark. In England we have world leaders in therapeutic child care. Distinguishing is important – see NCERCC-Distinguishing-Residential-Child-Care-Therapeutic-Child-Care-Treatment-and-Trauma-informed-Residential-Care-Models-final-040626-v-1.pdf
Many of the children here have suffered physical, emotional and social neglect, and issues such as self-harm, insomnia and eating disorders are common.
The range of needs in Denmark are often of a different order than homes in England, they are not necessarily like-for-like comparisons.
Unlike children’s homes in England, where many children report being isolated and cut off from family and friends, here children are encouraged to have friends stay at the weekends and holidays, there are regular parents evenings, including a Christmas banquet.
The idea of distance needs to be understood with nuance. It is psychological not only geographic. It can bring a feeling of security and safety that is never highlighted in coverage.
Each child also has a team of two to three staff members working with them on their education and wellbeing. In a semi-independent flat on the top floor live the older residents, aged 17 and above, who have their own living area and kitchen as they start to transition into adulthood.
Each child has 3+ grown-ups? MacAllister has said this fragments relationships. In England therapeutic parenting has one child: keywork/co-worker.
We have argued for staying on and been denied even tho it is possible in legislation. The government allowed local Staying Close to fall away to replace it with Supported Accommodation, 16.5 year olds onwards living together often without any continuous caring presence. Currently a child can leave a children’s home at 16.5 having arrived at 15. Is this good parenting? Josh MacAllister has argued for Supported Accommodation.
The young people buy their own food and do their own chores, under the guidance of staff, preparing them for independent life beyond the home. They are allowed to stay in the home up until the age of 23, and encouraged to return for regular visits beyond that age.
Children often see their residential workers as the people with whom they had their first meaningful relationship and return to their home often.
This is a far cry from children’s homes in England, which teenagers must leave as soon as they turn 18, part of the cliff-edge loss of support that is causing the early deaths of care leavers.
Entirely government led.
MacAlister said he may change this. “Getting rid of the really binary date of birth point to decide where you live is something I’m really persuaded by,” he said. “I hear of children being forced to move when they turn 18, even if they’re in the middle of sitting their A-levels. We have to move away from that.”
Yes.
He also wants to import some of the culture from Danish children’s homes, particularly their focus on personal growth and maintaining family relationships.
We do this here. How does he not know this is in the Children’s Homes Quality Standards and Ofsted inspection framework?
“A lot of residential care in England is actually about adults containing their own anxiety and concerns about teenagers, and that’s a really poor model,” MacAlister said.
A recent book chapter addresses this issue – ‘Is it evidence or anxiety driving the move to smaller homes’ Jonthan Stanley Perfect Little Children’s Home – Dialogue. Homes are taking care of others anxiety.
“The first question is always ‘how do we protect ourselves from risk?’ which is not what we should be asking first. It’s very different here in Denmark.”
Denmark is a different culture. If children behave in the same ways they are seen understood responded to differently.
The quality of staff is crucial, and something at the heart of the ongoing review, which is being led by Emmanuel Akpan-Inwang, the director of Lighthouse Pedagogy Trust, which runs a children’s home in Sutton based on pedagogy principles.
“What’s interesting about Denmark is working in a children’s home is a career that people really want to do,” he said. “It’s competitive. Homes are able to select really great people. They support and train them. They stay in the sector for long periods of time.
Homes here resist the negativity.
There are few who can stay in the sector given the pay.
“But we can’t simply lift and shift the system to England. The Danes have spent more than 40 years developing it. But we can learn from it.”
At Josephine Schneider’s House, many staff members have been there 10 years or longer. In the UK, about 53% of children’s home staff have worked in the sector for three years or less. Poor pay, working conditions and a lack of training force many to leave the sector early.
Exactly!
But underpinning Danish children’s homes is extensive state funding – a third of homes are publicly owned, 42% are not-for-profit and 27% are private profit.
In England all homes are publicly funded. The not-for-profit and charities make the same profit margins often repaying social (privately funded) finance
By contrast, in England, 83% of children’s homes places are now privately run, with some operators recording profit margins of more than 20%.
True. Quality and profit need addressing.
The government has passed laws giving itself the power to intervene and cap profits by private providers but has yet to use it, with MacAlister saying they need to wait for a new “market oversight body” to provide full transparency of exactly how much money is being made before they can push ahead.
The situation has been allowed to get to a position where if private providers exit we do not have responses.
The government of Wales is moving more quickly, and will ban all for-profit providers in children’s social care by 2030.
True and not true. Actually Wales has found ways to extenuate rather than eliminate the continuation of profit.
But MacAlister said it would not be easy to replicate this in England, where numbers are much bigger.
“We need to massively boost local authorities so they can take back control of the whole purchasing process, curb demand by making sure more children can live in foster homes or kinship arrangements, and shape a system on our terms, not one that is driven by profit,” MacAlister said.
Is he suggesting using family-based care unpaid.?
Is he denying/rationing appropriate care (curb demand)?
The letter
To The Guardian Letters page
The article comparing English children’s homes unfavourably to Denmark’s has vital factual and contextual nuance missing. Space permits addressing only some.
It is unclear in what crisis the homes are ‘ mired’. Ofsted’s official statistics show continued levels of inspection ratings. Of the now 4,800 homes offering 17,500 places at mainly 3 or 4 per home, smaller than Denmark, 12% are Outstanding, 73.4% Good, 23% are Requiring improvement to be Good, and 1.7% Inadequate. Furthermore, 82% of homes are judged Good or Outstanding for how well children are helped and protected. Three recent research reports record positive outcomes. We have world-class homes, some supporting development across the globe.
England has world leaders in residential therapeutic child care, the right sort of homes to meet the multiple, co- occurring, interacting, high level needs of English children placed in residential care. Denmark uses it residential care differently. An English home would never house12 children across a six-to-23 (child?) age range due to strict safeguarding regulations.
Degree-level qualifications and professional status for residential workers have been denied by successive governments. This denial keeps pay low, forcing excellent staff out. Yet, workers continually resist systemic negativity, forming the first meaningful relationships with children.
Instead of looking to “lift and shift” foreign models, the government could recognise the jewels in its own crown, addressing the low pay it has perpetuated by a Fair Pay agreement as being pursued for adult care, and support expertise with thorough learning and development leading to professional qualifications at least to the equivalent of social work, as in Denmark.
249 words
