Skip to content
Looking to read the latest articles? Please click here

DfE residential child care workforce review to highlight how it can transform to act for itself

The forthcoming DfE residential child care workforce professional 

development review report is highly likely to show the distinction between residential child care (RCC) ‘in itself’ and ‘for itself’.

It is highly likely there will be recognition of RCC  in itself, as a sector defined as a group of people who share the same economic relationship to the production of care, that is as they do not own their workplaces and they must sell their caring for a wage in order to survive.

Currently RCCWs may not realise they share common interests, and  often view themselves as individuals competing against one another for jobs, wages, or promotions.

RCCWs exist as a statistical or economic category, rather than as an organised social care factor.

Once the report is published the situation changes,  opening up potential for RCCWs to take forwards and further the recognition as a profession and practice, to act ‘for itself’. This is definition by collective consciousness and advocacy.

This occurs when RCCWs develops consciousness of their position and potential as a social care factor through an active awareness of its shared exploitation and collective power.

A shared identity emerges as RCCWs recognise that their situation is not defined personally or by their employer but is the definition resulting from the place of social care in the broader economic system.

To date the future of RCC has been debated between government (local and national) and providers with the focus of policy and property and profit.

Providers may find in the conclusions a government offer to be willingly co-opted compromising the ability to define their own future in order to continue in business.

This would be the  colonisation of the sector, curtailing its ability to determine the definition of its role and function in children’s social care.

The relationship to procurement, the future size, the shape, the methods, outcomes all are highly likely to be materially adversely affected by the wider children’s social care policy (especially regional care co-operatives) and  review, and be highly deleterious to RCCWs and  children (no notion of rights of RCCWs eg Fair Pay, or of children’s rights to care).

However, it is in this way the review makes the potential for RCC and RCCWs to act ‘for itself’ as the review makes the common interests of RCCWs and children in general across the sector.

The common factor of exploitation by underfunding is exposed. The reason for the regional care coops is to reduce expenditure by reduction of fees, and  homes and length of stay as stated in the Minister’s speech at the ADACS conference, residential will be smaller and more purposeful.

Care is being determined in itself by objective economic conditions, individualism and competition, passivity or fragmentation.

Care acting for itself has an awareness and solidarity, a unity and collective identity, and is active, organised, and transformative.

Highlighting how Residential Child Care Workers (RCCWs) shift from passive economic units to an active, unified factor we need to illustrate how this distinction plays out in practice.

RCC “In Itself”: Fragmentation and Market Survival

Currently, the sector largely exists as a collection of isolated workers and competing providers, dictated by local authority commissioning, Ofsted frameworks, and private equity or corporate margins.

  • Competing for “Better” Providers: Instead of challenging sector-wide low pay, an RCCW might leave a private provider paying low wages and pension, terms and conditions  to join a local authority home with slightly better wages and better pension, terms and conditions. This treats poor working conditions as an individual employer issue rather than a systemic problem.
  • Isolation Across Shift Patterns: Because residential homes operate 24/7 with small teams per shift scattered across many homes  RCCWs rarely meet peers from other homes. Burnout and secondary  are often explained as personal resilience failures rather than occupational hazards caused by under-resourced staffing ratios.
  • Co-opted Practice: Workers are trained to deliver specific, commodified models of care chosen by providers to win local authority tenders. Practice is shaped by procurement criteria rather than the autonomous professional judgement of the workforce.
  • Passive Reception of Policy: Major structural shifts, such as the rollout of Regional Care Cooperatives or caps on profits are debated between the Department for Education (DfE), the LGA, ADCS, CMA), and providers. Workers remain statistical data points in workforce turnover reports.

RCC “For Itself”: Collective Consciousness and Solidarity

Moving to a sector “for itself” means RCCWs recognise that the devaluation of their work and the instability experienced by children in care stem from the exact same root: the underfunding that was a prime component of the Blair government, to outsource, and to introduce  commodification,  marketisation and underfunding of care.

  • Linking Worker Rights to Children’s Rights: Rather than framing pay rises merely as a cost-of-living issue, workers actively campaign on the basis that low pay drives high staff turnover, which directly harms children by severing attachment relationships. Recognising this shared interest turns wage demands into an ethical defence of children’s rights.
  • Cross-Sector Unionisation and Professional Registration: RCCWs move beyond isolated workplace grievances to join trade unions or professional bodies specifically to demand a Fair Pay Agreement for residential child care, national professional training, registration, and qualifications, putting them on par with teachers and social workers, and the health sector colleagues.
  • Challenging the “Regional Care Cooperative” Cost-Cutting Agenda: When a review or government policy proposes Regional Care Cooperatives aimed at reducing placements and shortening lengths of stay to save money, workers organise collectively to submit counter-evidence. They use their frontline expertise to argue that rushing children out of residential child care is driven by economics not need or care.
  • Reclaiming the Definition of Care: Instead of letting government, private providers or commissioners, or any others,  define “good outcomes” through cost-per-placement metrics, organised RCCWs articulate their own professional practice. They collectively push back against the “colonisation” of care by profit motives, advocating for a model of care rooted in relational stability rather than market efficiency.

Summary of the Shift Dimension RCC “In Itself” (Current Reality) RCC “For Itself” (Post-Review

Potential) View of Low Pay
“I need to find a better-paying home”
becomes
“The care market relies on underpaying us to generate profit or save council budgets.”

Response to Burnout
Leaving the sector quietly (high turnover)
becomes
Collective demands for safe staffing ratios and mandated clinical supervision.

Relationship to Children
Delivering commissioned “care packages” within strict budget limits
becomes
Standing in solidarity with care-experienced people to demand stable, lifelong relationships.

Practice Voice
Represented by provider associations (who prioritise business survival)
becomes
Represented by independent worker collectives and unions (who prioritise care quality and worker dignity).

By exposing how underfunding and market structures dictate both the precarity of the workforce and the shrinking availability of homes for children, the forthcoming review can act as a catalyst, turning an isolated workforce into a self-aware social force capable of reshaping the sector.