Skip to content
Looking to read the latest articles? Please click here

Correcting the record – Wales has extenuated not eliminated profits from care

NCERCC is taking opportunity to correct a generalised misunderstanding regarding not-for-profit legislation in Wales. It does not eliminate but extenuates the extraction of profit.

The current ‘not for profit’ policy does not eliminate profit as private equity/social finance can still extract value in various ways.

On enquiring the Removing Profit team have advised NCERCC that the policy does not seek to prohibit all forms of external finance. Not-for-profit organisations, including charities, accessing external finance  may make interest payments or make other legitimate financing costs. They explain the policy objective is to ensure that restricted children’s services operate on a not-for-profit basis and are not run for private gain.

It is argued that it does not follow that every payment made by a provider to an external organisation constitutes profit extraction in the sense intended by the legislation, and that the legislation also includes safeguards relating to financial arrangements that may undermine a provider’s not-for-profit purposes.

They appreciate a view that in naming the policy ‘eliminate profit’ is that any financial return connected to restricted children’s services associated with external finance is inconsistent with the principle of removing profit. However they conclude ‘that is a broader position than the approach taken within the legislative framework’

Also in the news

Recently Mark Drakeford , until recently First Minister of the Senedd/Welsh Government, told a Welsh Labour Grassroots fringe meeting of ‘a way forward for progressive policies’ and going ‘further over public control of public services (to) bring them fully into public ownership’.

He said, “The care service we have is not fit for what we want, and we should be removing the profit motive from it and turn the existing providers into co-operatives.”

Cooperatives were not included, though argued for by some, in the policy development when Labour were in government.  The 4 types of undertaking in the Wales children’s social care legislation allowed are  charitable company limited by guarantee without a share capital; charitable incorporated organisation; charitable registered society; or, community interest company limited by guarantee without a share capital